Accueil »
La communauté »
Rapports de bug »
Rapport n°26872
Tous les rapports
Rapports de bug sur Luxor
#26872: "No action was given as a choice or executed when Horus card was used (to enter tomb)"
#26872: "No action was given as a choice or executed when Horus card was used (to enter tomb)"
Quel est le sujet de ce rapport ?
Que s'est-il passé ? Merci de choisir ci-dessous
Règles : une règle du jeu n'a pas été respectée
Que s'est-il passé ? Merci de choisir ci-dessous
Règles : une règle du jeu n'a pas été respectée
Veuillez vérifier s'il existe déjà un rapport sur le même sujet
Si oui, veuillez VOTER pour ce rapport. Les rapports ayant le plus de votes auront la PRIORITÉ !
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Description détaillée
• Merci de copier-coller le message d'erreur qui s'affiche à l'écran, s'il y a lieu.
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Veuillez expliquer ce que vous vouliez faire, ce que vous avez fait et ce qu'il s'est passé
96• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• SVP copiez / collez ici le texte affiché en anglais au lieu de votre langue. Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Ce texte est-il disponible dans le système de traduction ? Si oui, a-t-il été traduit depuis plus de 24 heures ?
96• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• Merci d'expliquer votre suggestion de manière précise et concise, de façon à ce qu'il soit aussi simple que possible de comprendre ce que vous voulez dire.
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• Qu'affichait l'écran lorsque vous avez été bloqué·e (Un écran vierge ? Une partie de l'interface du jeu ? Un message d'erreur ?)
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• Quelle partie des règles n'a pas été respectée par l'adaptation BGA ?
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• La violation de règle est-elle visible dans le replay de la partie ? Si oui, à quel numéro de coup ?
96• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• Quelle action de jeu vouliez-vous faire ?
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Qu'avez-vous essayé de faire pour déclencher cette action de jeu ?
96• Que s'est-il passé lorsque vous avez essayé de faire cela (message d'erreur, message dans la barre d'état du jeu...) ?
• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• À quelle étape de la partie le problème est-il apparu ? Quelles instructions le jeu affichait-il ?
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Que s'est-il passé lorsque vous avez essayé de faire cette action de jeu (message d'erreur, message dans la barre d'état du jeu...) ?
96• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• Veuillez décrire le problème d'affichage. Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• SVP copiez / collez ici le texte affiché en anglais au lieu de votre langue. Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Ce texte est-il disponible dans le système de traduction ? Si oui, a-t-il été traduit depuis plus de 24 heures ?
96• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
• Merci d'expliquer votre suggestion de manière précise et concise, de façon à ce qu'il soit aussi simple que possible de comprendre ce que vous voulez dire.
This happened in the same game as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=26871
A rules clarification may be needed. In this game on the move in question, in addition to the bug filed above, there appears to be 2 bugs:
1) No action choice was given after playing the “advance all adventurers” Horus card and advancing into the tomb chamber. (I actually advanced 2 adventurers, which caused its own different bug, filed separately.) This was unlike previous plays of this type of Horus card, when it would ask to select #1 an adventurer (albeit unnecessary), #2 a space (also unnecessary), then #3 an adventurer whose action to invoke (necessary). For that move, it only asked #1 and #2 and never asked #3.
2) No action was executed. Only a (single) sarcophagus was gained, but no action. I don’t believe claiming a sarcophagus is an action according to the rules — see below. However if it were an action, then the user should still be given a choice in case one of the other actions is more beneficial.
The relevant rules from the Queen rulebook:
Performing an Action: ”When an adventurer has completed its movement, the player performs the action of the tile on which the movement ended.” Actions are on tiles. The rules then specifically list out the 4 different tile types that have actions (Treasure/Temple/Horus/Osirus).
End of Game/Moving into the Final Chamber: There is no mention of actions anywhere in this section. The reward text is: “The first adventurer to enter the tomb chamber claims the sarcophagus worth 5 VPs. The second adventurer to reach this space will take the other one, worth 3 VPs. Both of these adventurers may belong to the same player. Other adventurers may still enter the tomb chamber during the final game round, using their key(s). However, they will not gain a sarcophagus.” As further evidence, the verb “claim” is not used anywhere else in describing actions — which suggests it is not an action but an automatic reward. However, rules clarification from the publisher may make sense here to confirm what the designer intended?
Horus card Summary/Advance all adventurers: “After the player has moved all of their active adventurers, they chose 1 to perform the action of the tile it is standing on.” Again, linking actions to tiles specifically. “Important! Even after using an “Advance all adventurers” card, a player can perform only 1 of the following actions: take 1 scarab or 1 wild card treasure tile or 1 treasure tile, or send 1 adventurer through a tunnel or draw 1 Horus card.” And once again, explicitly listing the only possible actions. Notably, claiming a sarcophagus is not one of allowed possibilities listed.
These all suggest that entering a tomb using the “Advance all adventurers” Horus card gives you one (or more, see bug #26871) sarcophagus as a reward AND still allows you to take an action — on any of the tiles your adventurers are on.• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Safari v13.1
Historique des rapports de bug
25 oct. 2020 6:08 • Sugs • Le bug n'a pas encore été reproduit par les développeurs:
see the other bug report for the additional bug that occurred on the same move: 1) game not ending, and 2) only one sarcophagus claimed when 2 adventurers advance simultaneously into the tomb
25 oct. 2020 8:24 • cpasbanal • Ce n'est pas un bug:
This was already discussed during the alpha stage of the game and validated by Travis from Queen Games.
Entering the tomb is not considered as an action because it is the default action that should be triggered by move all the adventurer so when entering the tomb, you cannot choose anything else than looting a sarcophagus and don't get credit for another action :)
Entering the tomb is not considered as an action because it is the default action that should be triggered by move all the adventurer so when entering the tomb, you cannot choose anything else than looting a sarcophagus and don't get credit for another action :)
25 oct. 2020 11:53 • diamant • Ce n'est pas un bug:
The rule says on page 2: "Next, the player performs the action shown on the tile upon which the adventurer ended its movement." The text on page 5 confirms that the only actions existing in this game are the actions of the tiles.
The tomb chamber has no tiles, only two sarcophagi. Therefore, you cannot say that looting a sarcophagus is an action, on the pretext of a so-called discussion whose existence or content cannot be verified.
You must consider the theoretical (though unlikely) situation where all adventurers of a player would enter the tomb chamber. Considering your answer, only one sarcophagus could be recovered at this time, and I presume that another adventurer present in the burial chamber will not be able to recover the second sarcophagus on the next turn. So, for this only player, the game would be over. With such a rule, it seems obvious to me that the use of keys should be optional, as long as the player can move at least one adventurer.
The tomb chamber has no tiles, only two sarcophagi. Therefore, you cannot say that looting a sarcophagus is an action, on the pretext of a so-called discussion whose existence or content cannot be verified.
You must consider the theoretical (though unlikely) situation where all adventurers of a player would enter the tomb chamber. Considering your answer, only one sarcophagus could be recovered at this time, and I presume that another adventurer present in the burial chamber will not be able to recover the second sarcophagus on the next turn. So, for this only player, the game would be over. With such a rule, it seems obvious to me that the use of keys should be optional, as long as the player can move at least one adventurer.
26 oct. 2020 8:13 • cpasbanal • Ce n'est pas un bug:
> on the pretext of a so-called discussion whose existence or content cannot be verified
No use to be agressive here, that won't help at all
What i am saying is:
- the game has been played over 2300 times
- especially by the game designer Travis Reynolds himself and his team and he validated the game implementation (prerequisite to move the game to beta)
- you can see any bug report and all the public discussions here
- you can see any message (especially Travis' ones) on the Luxor group player (boardgamearena.com/group?id=6869130)
About your specific case where all the adventurers would move to the tomb chamber at once, it can happen as well as being stuck with no key at the end of the game. Hence the rule where players can "Pass" when they cannot move.
Eventually, i'd just say that this is how i implemented the game and i will keep it that way for the reasons explained above :)
hope you'll like the game anyway
No use to be agressive here, that won't help at all
What i am saying is:
- the game has been played over 2300 times
- especially by the game designer Travis Reynolds himself and his team and he validated the game implementation (prerequisite to move the game to beta)
- you can see any bug report and all the public discussions here
- you can see any message (especially Travis' ones) on the Luxor group player (boardgamearena.com/group?id=6869130)
About your specific case where all the adventurers would move to the tomb chamber at once, it can happen as well as being stuck with no key at the end of the game. Hence the rule where players can "Pass" when they cannot move.
Eventually, i'd just say that this is how i implemented the game and i will keep it that way for the reasons explained above :)
hope you'll like the game anyway
26 oct. 2020 9:33 • diamant • Ce n'est pas un bug:
I don’t want to sound unpleasant, but the fact is that your connection is generating an error (BGA service error), and I don’t have access to the linked discussion you’re talking about, even having been part of the reviewers. I think it’s the same for other BGA members.
It seems to me that an important rule change such as deciding that the recovery of a sarcophagus is an action, and in addition a mandatory action, should be set out on a page accessible to all.
The result of such a change is that a second investigator entering the tomb chamber during the same player's turn does not recover a sarcophagus. This disadvantage could be avoided if the player was not ever required to use a key available to enter the tomb chamber (unless this is the only possible move) or if the use of the key was considered as part of the action (so only one key could be used during a player’s turn).
It seems to me that an important rule change such as deciding that the recovery of a sarcophagus is an action, and in addition a mandatory action, should be set out on a page accessible to all.
The result of such a change is that a second investigator entering the tomb chamber during the same player's turn does not recover a sarcophagus. This disadvantage could be avoided if the player was not ever required to use a key available to enter the tomb chamber (unless this is the only possible move) or if the use of the key was considered as part of the action (so only one key could be used during a player’s turn).
26 oct. 2020 20:45 • cpasbanal • Ce n'est pas un bug:
Hi,
I was just linking to Luxor group. Just have to play once to be part of the group and I think you can then see the whole history of discussions.
Besides, in order to discuss this point of rule deeper, I would suggest you open a topic on the forum, this is the best way to have an open debate and decide which implementation I should eventually choose.
I was just linking to Luxor group. Just have to play once to be part of the group and I think you can then see the whole history of discussions.
Besides, in order to discuss this point of rule deeper, I would suggest you open a topic on the forum, this is the best way to have an open debate and decide which implementation I should eventually choose.
Ajouter à ce rapport
Veuillez ajouter ici toute information qui semble pertinente pour reproduire ce bug ou comprendre votre suggestion :
- Un autre n° de table / n° de coup
- Appuyer sur F5 a-t-il résolu le problème ?
- Le problème est-il apparu plusieurs fois ? À chaque fois ? Aléatoirement ?
- Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
Changer le statut du rapport en :
bug?id=26872
