#83100: "My suggestion is to allow Troyes players to choose a setup without the Archer"
Quel est le sujet de ce rapport ?
Que s'est-il passé ? Merci de choisir ci-dessous
Que s'est-il passé ? Merci de choisir ci-dessous
Veuillez vérifier s'il existe déjà un rapport sur le même sujet
Si oui, veuillez VOTER pour ce rapport. Les rapports ayant le plus de votes auront la PRIORITÉ !
# | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
---|
Description détaillée
• Merci de copier-coller le message d'erreur qui s'affiche à l'écran, s'il y a lieu.
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Veuillez expliquer ce que vous vouliez faire, ce que vous avez fait et ce qu'il s'est passé
• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• SVP copiez / collez ici le texte affiché en anglais au lieu de votre langue. Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Ce texte est-il disponible dans le système de traduction ? Si oui, a-t-il été traduit depuis plus de 24 heures ?
• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• Merci d'expliquer votre suggestion de manière précise et concise, de façon à ce qu'il soit aussi simple que possible de comprendre ce que vous voulez dire.
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• Qu'était-il affiché à l'écran lorsque vous avez été bloqué·e (Écran vierge ? Une partie de l'interface de jeu ? Un message d'erreur ?)
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• Quelle partie des règles n'a pas été respectée par l'adaptation BGA
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• La violation de règle est-elle visible dans le replay de la partie ? Si oui, à quel numéro de coup ?
• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• Quelle action de jeu vouliez-vous faire ?
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Qu'essayez-vous de faire pour déclencher cette action de jeu ?
• Que se passe-t-il lorsque vous essayez de faire cela (message d'erreur, message de la barre d'état du jeu, ...) ?
• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• À quelle étape de la partie le problème est-il apparu (quel était le texte d'instruction du jeu) ?
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Que se passe-t-il lorsque vous essayez de faire une action de jeu (message d'erreur, message de la barre d'état du jeu, ...) ?
• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• Veuillez décrire le problème d'affichage. Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• SVP copiez / collez ici le texte affiché en anglais au lieu de votre langue. Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Ce texte est-il disponible dans le système de traduction ? Si oui, a-t-il été traduit depuis plus de 24 heures ?
• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
• Merci d'expliquer votre suggestion de manière précise et concise, de façon à ce qu'il soit aussi simple que possible de comprendre ce que vous voulez dire.
Troyes has the potential to be a perfectly balanced game that allows for a variety of strategies. One can plan ahead to collect money, influence, citizens in building and such - and good planning is usually rewarded through the action cards. However, there is one exception - the Archer. You can activate it 4-5 times and score multiple points - or activate it 9 times and place ONE cube, if not none! Once that happens, one's game is completely ruined, there is no recovery option after wasting so many resources. Staying away from the Archer doesn't help either because if another player does go there and is _lucky_ (nothing to do with being good!), their advantage is so big that the result is the same: no way to recover.
I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin. So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance. There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution. The only one available seems to be to abandon/restart the game every time the Archer shows up. My group did that for a while, then most players got tired of it (on one occasion we had to restart FIVE TIMES before we finally managed to get rid of that card). So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion. Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others). This simple change would allow everybody to actually enjoy the game, not half-suffer through it.
Thank you!• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v110
Historique des rapports de bug
BGA really needs to allow downvotes as well, particularly if developers are going to use the number of upvotes as any sort of indication of popularity/support.
In lieu of a downvote button, however, I will instead dispute the substance of and assumptions behind the critiques and appeals put forth by the poster of this suggestion:
> I understand that some people might care less about fairness - and more about adrenalin.
This is a false dichotomy. Some of us care about playing the game that the /designers/ designed, rather than some derivative that others wish to hack into being by adding or removing rules that they like or don't like, respectively.
> So, they don't mind if a great strategic game is turned into a game of chance.
You know who else doesn't mind? The designers. They published this game with the Archer as one of the possible cards that could appear in any given game. That tells me that they're perfectly fine with this level of chance in the game.
You're free to dislike that if you so choose, but don't pretend that you're somehow the only one who cares about fairness or the "greatness" of this game. Why should your opinion count for more than that of the designers?
> There are others, though - those who do care about the actual quality of the game. I am one of them, and I've tried to find a solution.
If you don't like the Archer, just say so and be done with it; but skip the cloak of nobility that you're pretending to wear in order to justify your preferred house rule. Why do you think that you care about this game's quality more than its designers do?
> My suggestion/request is simple: be fair to different people, not just those of a particular opinion.
What definition of "fair" and "fairness" are you using that would let you modify someone else's creation? If I don't like the ending to a book or a movie, what definition of "fairness" would allow me to rewrite that ending? There is none.
One is free to read a book, watch a movie, or play a game created by someone else and to like it or dislike it according to one's own criteria–but not to /modify/ it, certainly not under a vague and ultimately self-serving claim of "fairness".
> So, we can't play Troyes online anymore :-(
Yes, you can. You just choose not to. Which you're free to do, of course. But don't present this choice as something that's forced upon you.
> Multiple games allow for variants (play with/without such-and-such card, among others).
Multiple games do allow that, yes, but this game is not one of them, and there's nothing in its rules that remotely suggests that it is.
It's important to understand that games are individual creations, such that the rules for one have precisely zero bearing on any other—just as how the premise of a book or movie does not mean that some other book or movie will share that same premise, or that a character from one fictional universe will exist in some other universe.
Some additional thoughts: banning the Archer will not automatically turn Troyes into "a great strategic game" that is somehow not also "a game of chance", to borrow your phrasing. How do I know? Because the game will still have the a) the rolling of dice in the Assemble Workforce phase of each round (you know, that phase of each round where /all/ dice are rolled) and b) the rerolling of dice via influence.
Unless you also plan to house-rule these aspects of the game (no, I'm not trying to give you ideas), it will be still possible to have disproportionately beneficial or detrimental rolls that could make or break one's game.
I myself experienced the latter in a recent in-person game where I influenced-rolled a 1 into a 1... and another 1... and another... five consecutive times. No Archer involved here, and therefore your proposed house rule would have made zero impact–but this was certainly a situation where there was "no way to recover". I cursed my luck, to be sure, but I'm not using that experience as an excuse to modify someone else's game.
Luck is inherent to Troyes. Accept it, or find a different game that has an amount of luck within tolerances that you can handle, but again, don't distort someone else's creation in a misguided attempt to fit your vision of "a perfectly balanced game".
To start with, you made hundredths of suggestions to modify someone else's games - it's just that those suggestions suited _you_. As for your luck, there is a rule in Troyes that you can flip your dice by paying 4 influence - and there are multiple ways to collect influence. So, you can plan for it. A good player can, in any case. And that's exactly what I meant by providing for every eventuality The Archer is the only card that gives no such option.
As for the rest... I've scrolled your tirade, and oh my - you love your imperative mood! So many "do" and "don't" combined with telling a complete stranger what and how he should enjoy. You've taken time and made quite an effort not to support a fellow player but to oppose a harmless change that doesn't hurt anybody, while helping some to enjoy the game more. Are you indeed from Canada? We, Canadians, are usually a much friendlier and nicer lot...
That said, I wonder if putting someone down in public and bossing around helps you to feel important, thus making you feel better about yourself, in general... If so, my heart goes out to you. I would rather not play Troyes online than have to treat people like you do, just to be able to bear myself...
Furthermore, to activate it that many times you're burning through some very expensive and powerful dice, which is a second trade off you have to make when using the Archer.
I'd argue a far more powerful card that come into play is the Pilgrimage. 7 points of any dice colour to gain VPS? Often the much better choice.
Ajouter à ce rapport
- Un autre n° de table / n° de coup
- La touche F5 a-t-elle résolu le problème ?
- Le problème est-il apparu plusieurs fois ? À chaque fois ? Aléatoirement ?
- Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.