Tous les rapports
Rapports de bug sur Carcassonne
#27954: "Make visible discarted tile !"
awaiting: Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs
Quel est le sujet de ce rapport ?
Que s'est-il passé ? Merci de choisir ci-dessous
Suggestion : à mon avis, la modification suivante améliorerait grandement l'implémentation du jeu
Description détaillée
• Merci d'expliquer votre suggestion de manière précise et concise, de façon à ce qu'il soit aussi simple que possible de comprendre ce que vous voulez dire.
When a player cant play a tile it is discarted, but this fact is very, VERY! well hidden before other players. I know its in history, but its not possible to track history in every game...
It is crutial to know what tile was discarted, it should be visible with some kind of alert ! Sometimes you prepare a special slot for this very one tile, wait all game till it appear, and at the end of game you find out that it was discarted as very beggning.
I dont know the official ruls but when you play in real life, when player discard a tile I ask him/her to show this tile (he can lie that he cant place it, and he can discard any tile...)
Is it realy that hard to implement a visible place with discarted carts ?
Its non that rare that CCCC,RRRR or FFFF tile can be easily discarted...• Quel est votre navigateur ?
Google Chrome v86
Historique des rapports de bug
10 nov. 2020 20:40 • Kurasant123 • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
No F5 will not help, only very visible place on board will solve this. Or alert like notes popup every time you enter table with notes you will be inforemed that tile was discarted (and for example checkbox to disable it in future with this game...)
10 nov. 2020 21:37 • TerranPL • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
Totally agree. Perfect solution would be to have some sort of message:
"[tile_icon] could not be played and was discarded"
Both players would have to press "Got it!" button before the message dissapears for each of them separately.
Best place for such message would be just below the top-center area when tile currently played is displayed.
"[tile_icon] could not be played and was discarded"
Both players would have to press "Got it!" button before the message dissapears for each of them separately.
Best place for such message would be just below the top-center area when tile currently played is displayed.
25 nov. 2020 18:17 • Kurasant123 • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
I did not mean to make it visible in "Show last moves". I ment to make it visible and noticable. As it was said before or as a message popup when player join table (like private notes), or in corner line below to "Tiles left" can be "Tiles tossed"
28 mai 2021 20:17 • Mingo • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
I agree with TerranPL's comments and suggestions. A pop-up notification is needed, and having to select "Got it" is a good idea.
The addition of a comment in the game log indicating that the tile has been discarded is not easily noticeable. Many players feel very strongly about the advantage if only one player knows that a particular tile has been discarded, and in the interest of fairness they inform their opponents when a tile is discarded. However, not everyone does this or is aware that it is an issue.
The addition of a comment in the game log indicating that the tile has been discarded is not easily noticeable. Many players feel very strongly about the advantage if only one player knows that a particular tile has been discarded, and in the interest of fairness they inform their opponents when a tile is discarded. However, not everyone does this or is aware that it is an issue.
24 oct. 2021 16:07 • statmatt • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
7Wonders has a 'discarded cards' count in the bottom corner of the game screen. Even something as simple as this would at least indicate to players that a discard has occurred.
TerranPL's suggestion is good. Having the discarded tiles displayed somewhere/on demand is a fair solution.
TerranPL's suggestion is good. Having the discarded tiles displayed somewhere/on demand is a fair solution.
22 janv. 2022 9:17 • aibj7 • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
I totally agree.
I like the 'discard cards' in the Botton corner of the game screen, like 7 wonders!
I like the 'discard cards' in the Botton corner of the game screen, like 7 wonders!
31 janv. 2022 15:01 • Lou1990lou • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
The rules officially state
"In some very rare cases, it may be impossible to place the tile. In those cases, simply return the tile to the box
and draw a new one" [page 5, under Summary]
So there should be no need for a discard pile as it will come back into play later.
If it doesn't come back into play then that means there is a bug in the game that is more than a suggestion.
"In some very rare cases, it may be impossible to place the tile. In those cases, simply return the tile to the box
and draw a new one" [page 5, under Summary]
So there should be no need for a discard pile as it will come back into play later.
If it doesn't come back into play then that means there is a bug in the game that is more than a suggestion.
2 févr. 2022 4:50 • SmilingDevil • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
Tiles that cant be placed are not returned into the pile to draw from. You don’t draw from the box.
4 févr. 2022 17:30 • palindnilap • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
I strongly support the suggestion. Actually I once had CCCC discarded and I thought it was a bug, that's why I came to this forum in the first place ! I hadn't thought about discarded tiles. So hidden information like that is also detrimental to the game experience of non-experts.
7 juil. 2022 14:35 • SquashEngineer • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
Alternatively:
a. shuffle the discarded tile back in the draw pile to be used later;
b. choose from three cards per turn, rather than one, to increase likelihood of play.
a. shuffle the discarded tile back in the draw pile to be used later;
b. choose from three cards per turn, rather than one, to increase likelihood of play.
21 août 2022 18:59 • Karpenter45 • Cette suggestion n'a pas encore été analysée par les développeurs:
Just make visible discarded card, because in long plays, it is not possible to read whole history to check if tile was or wasn't discarded.
Ajouter à ce rapport
Veuillez ajouter ici toute information qui semble pertinente pour reproduire ce bug ou comprendre votre suggestion :
- Un autre n° de table / n° de coup
- Appuyer sur F5 a-t-il résolu le problème ?
- Le problème est-il apparu plusieurs fois ? À chaque fois ? Aléatoirement ?
- Si vous avez une capture d'écran de ce bug (pensez-y !), vous pouvez utiliser Imgur.com pour la télécharger et copier-coller le lien ici.
